BLOG

Retractable Awnings vs Screens: Costs and Use Cases

Retractable awnings and outdoor screens are two of the most popular ways to improve patio comfort. Both provide shade and weather relief, but they work in completely different ways. A retractable awning extends outward to create overhead shade, while screens drop vertically to block sun, wind, glare, and insects. The right solution depends on your outdoor lifestyle, climate, patio direction, and comfort expectations.

This guide compares how each system performs in day to day use, how they handle heat and glare, how they affect visibility and airflow, and which is more cost effective for specific patio layouts. For visuals and real projects, explore the main inspiration gallery at West Shore Shade as you read.

What Retractable Awnings Do and How They Work

Retractable awnings extend from the wall or roofline to create immediate overhead shade. They use a folding arm or cassette design and operate either manually or with motorization.

Core Benefits of Awnings

  • Strong overhead shade
  • Cools patios significantly
  • Ideal for midday sun
  • Helps protect outdoor furniture
  • Extends shade across wide open spaces

Awnings are particularly effective for patios that receive intense overhead sunlight. Since they project outward, they block sun before it reaches seating areas, grills, or outdoor dining setups.

To explore available awning configurations, fabrics, and arm styles, review the dedicated category page at Awnings.

What Outdoor Screens Do and How They Work

Outdoor screens lower vertically, creating a protective wall that manages sun, wind, insects, and privacy. They can be installed on existing openings such as patios, pergolas, lanais, garages, and commercial dining areas.

Core Benefits of Screens

  • Block low angle sun
  • Reduce glare
  • Control insects
  • Provide daytime privacy
  • Soften wind
  • Maintain outward visibility

Screens are more versatile than awnings because they address issues that occur at eye level. They are especially valuable on patios that remain hot in the late afternoon or suffer from insect activity at dusk.

To learn about screen materials, openness levels, and automation features, visit Motorized Screens.

Shade and Heat Control: Which Works Better

Awnings and screens produce shade differently.

Awnings for Overhead Shade

Awnings significantly reduce radiant heat from the sun by stopping it before it reaches the patio surface or outdoor furniture. This reduces temperatures immediately and keeps patio floors cooler.

Screens for Horizontal and Angled Sun

Solar screens are designed to filter sun coming from the horizon or at low angles. This makes them excellent for afternoon comfort when the sun appears at the side rather than above.

Ideal Shade Matches

  • Midday heat: awning
  • Afternoon glare: screen
  • Full day high performance: combine awning plus screen

Many modern patios use both systems, allowing homeowners to control shade overhead and vertically as the sun moves.

For more detailed sun strategy planning, review the heat management section inside Motorized Patio Screens: A Complete 2026 Buyer Guide.

Glare Reduction and Outdoor TV Viewing

Screens outperform awnings for glare management. Dark mesh fabrics filter light much like sunglasses, making it easier to read, work, or watch TV outdoors.

Awnings reduce brightness but cannot stop lateral glare. Screens solve this by placing a filtering surface directly in the sightline.

Best for Outdoor Entertainment

  • Screens for glare control
  • Awnings for overhead comfort
  • Combination system for balanced lighting

Screens with 3 to 5 percent openness are considered ideal for outdoor TVs.

Airflow and Comfort Levels

Airflow affects how usable a patio is in hot climates.

Awnings and Airflow

Awnings do not restrict airflow since they shade from above. They reduce heat without diminishing breeze, making them feel cooler in humid environments.

Screens and Airflow

Screens reduce airflow slightly because of the fabric, with reductions based on openness percentage. Bug screens allow maximum breeze. Solar screens with low openness restrict airflow more.

Which Wins

  • Awnings win for total airflow
  • Screens win for controlled airflow with insect protection

If airflow is essential, consider pairing an awning with higher openness screens.

Insect Control Differences

This is an area where screens dominate.

Screens for Bug Protection

Solar screens and bug screens prevent insects from entering seating areas, especially at dusk. Awnings cannot stop insects since they offer no barrier at the sides.

Best Choice for Mosquito Heavy Areas

Screens are the clear winner.

To explore bug control in garage settings or multipurpose spaces, see Garage Door Screen which shows how mesh fabric performs across different room types.

Visibility and Outdoor Views

Screens and awnings interact with your view differently.

Screens

Dark solar fabrics provide excellent visibility and reduce glare. Light fabrics create a brighter patio but reduce clarity. Bug screens preserve visibility almost perfectly.

Awnings

Awnings do not obstruct views since they sit overhead. However, they do not reduce glare as effectively as screens.

Best for Scenic Views

Screens with dark, mid range openness often provide the clearest, most comfortable outward visibility.

Privacy Performance

Privacy becomes increasingly important in neighborhood patios.

Screens Offer Daytime Privacy

Solar screens allow you to see out while blocking people from seeing in during daylight. Bug screens do not offer much privacy.

Awnings Offer Little Privacy

Awnings shade from above but do not cover the sides, which limits privacy applications.

To add deeper privacy to indoor rooms adjacent to the patio, consider pairing outdoor treatments with Interior Shades.

Weather Handling and Exposure

Awnings and screens behave differently in changing weather.

Awnings and Rain

Retractable awnings can handle light rain depending on angle but should be retracted in storms.

Screens and Weather

Solar screens soften wind and can limit sideways rain. Bug screens allow rain to pass through.

For patios requiring partial enclosure from weather, reference how lanai systems handle exposure at Lanai.

Patio Types and Best Matches

Each patio layout benefits differently from awnings and screens.

Open Patios With Harsh Midday Sun

Awnings are the primary shading tool.

Patios With Afternoon Glare

Screens excel by targeting low angle sun.

Lanais

Screens suit lanais because they close vertical openings naturally.

Commercial Patios

Restaurants and storefronts prefer screens for usable outdoor seating and reduced glare. See examples at Commercial Shades.

Mixed Climate Patios

Many homeowners install both for maximum flexibility.

Cost Differences Between Awnings and Screens

Pricing depends on size, fabric type, motorization, and mounting conditions.

Awnings

Cost more for wide projections and high performance fabrics.

Screens

Cost varies based on openness, track type, and motorization. Solar fabrics increase price compared to bug mesh.

Combination systems cost more but deliver the best year round comfort.

For regional pricing factors, see the service coverage map at Service Areas.

Maintenance and Care

Both systems require periodic upkeep.

Awnings

  • Clean fabric yearly
  • Retract during storms
  • Check tension arms seasonally

Screens

  • Rinse mesh regularly
  • Clean tracks
  • Inspect fabric for debris

Proper maintenance preserves longevity and reduces service issues.

Awnings and Screens: Which Lasts Longer

Longevity depends on exposure, use frequency, and fabric type.

Awnings often last many years when retracted during storms. Screens last similarly long when cleaned regularly and installed with corrosion resistant components.

Coastal environments require extra care for both.

Should You Combine Awnings and Screens

Many homeowners choose both systems for maximum comfort. Awnings cool the patio during midday, while screens handle glare, wind, privacy, and bugs in late afternoon and evening.

Combination systems:

  • Reduce heat from above
  • Filter glare from the sides
  • Maintain airflow
  • Protect from insects
  • Create a more comfortable outdoor room

Homes with multiple sun exposures see the biggest advantage.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better for heat control

Awnings win for overhead heat, screens win for low angle glare.

Which is better for insects

Screens are the only option that control bugs effectively.

Can screens replace an awning

Screens help with glare and heat, but do not provide overhead shade.

Which is better for privacy

Solar screens provide daytime privacy. Awnings do not.

Do awnings and screens work together

Yes. Homes with both enjoy the most consistent comfort.

Which is easier to maintain

Both require simple cleaning, but screens need more frequent rinsing.

Can I motorize both

Yes. Motorized awnings and motorized screens are common upgrades.

Which lasts longer

Both last many years with proper care and retraction in storms.

Which is best for commercial patios

Screens perform better for business environments due to glare control and wind buffering.

Conclusion

Conclusion: How to Choose Between Awnings and Screens

Retractable awnings and outdoor screens each deliver powerful benefits. Awnings provide unbeatable overhead shade for midday sun. Screens block insects, wind, glare, and lateral sun. Your patio orientation, climate, and lifestyle determine which system fits best.

Final Takeaways

  • Choose awnings for overhead heat control and large seating areas.
  • Choose screens for glare control, privacy, and insect protection.
  • Combine both for the best all day performance.